A Peripheral Weapon?

Main Themes and Topics

A Peripheral Weapon? by David J. Childs presents a thorough examination of the historical and strategic significance of the tank in World War I. The book challenges the long-standing perception of the British War Office and General Headquarters (GHQ) in France as being resistant to technological advancements and overly reliant on traditional cavalry tactics. Childs argues that this portrayal is not entirely accurate, shedding light on the War Office's crucial involvement in the development and deployment of tanks during the war. The book delves into the formation and role of various committees, such as the Tank Committee, the New or Advisory Tank Committee, the Tank Directorate, and the Tank Board, in orchestrating the collaboration between the tank users at the frontlines in France and the producers within the Ministry of Munitions.

Writing Style and Tone

David J. Childs employs a scholarly and analytical tone throughout A Peripheral Weapon?, making it an insightful resource for historians and enthusiasts of military history. The writing is clear and precise, with a strong emphasis on research and historical evidence. Childs effectively balances technical details with broader strategic analysis, making the book accessible to both academics and general readers with an interest in World War I and military innovation.

Criticism

Some readers might find the book's focus predominantly on the British perspective to be somewhat limiting. While Childs provides a comprehensive exploration of the British War Office's role in tank development, those looking for a broader international context or a more diverse set of viewpoints may be left wanting. Additionally, the detailed examination of bureaucratic processes and committee structures might be considered overwhelming for readers who prefer a more narrative-driven historical account.

Brief Summary

In A Peripheral Weapon?, David J. Childs examines the development and significance of the tank during World War I, arguing against the traditional view of the British military establishment as anti-technological. Through rigorous research, Childs explores the influential role of the British War Office in tank production and deployment, highlighting how this support was crucial to the tank's success as a transformative military innovation. By dissecting the collaboration between military and industrial entities, Childs provides a nuanced understanding of the tank's evolution from a nascent invention to a formidable component of warfare by the war's end.