Battleships

Brief Summary

Battleships by William H. Garzke offers a detailed exploration of U.S. Navy battleships and battlecruisers. It encompasses a comprehensive history from the early 1930s to the early 1990s. The book delves into design and construction, operational careers, and eventual fate of these naval giants. Insights include the technical challenges faced during their service, including damage resistance, and a revised analysis of major incidents, like the tragic turret explosion on the USS Iowa in 1989. The work also unveils President Franklin D. Roosevelt's significant influence on warship design and deployment strategies, highlighting his role in shaping U.S. naval power. Further revelations include developments in gunfire control and proposed ship modifications.

Main Themes and Topics

This volume is rich with themes revolving around naval military history, ship design, engineering challenges, and tactical innovation. A central theme is the ongoing evolution and modernization of battleships through the decades, especially during significant conflicts like World War II. The book also emphasizes the strategic decisions and political influences impacting naval development, notably the direct involvement of President Franklin D. Roosevelt in ship design decisions. Additionally, it explores technical advancements in long-range gunfire control and discusses strategic reactivation and retirement decisions of various battleships, reflecting their enduring significance in naval history.

Writing Style and Tone

William H. Garzke employs a meticulous and scholarly writing style throughout Battleships. The tone is authoritative and informative, befitting the detailed subject matter. His analytical approach provides depth and context to the narrative, making it an essential resource for readers with a vested interest in naval history and engineering. Despite the complexity of the topics, the book remains accessible, offering detailed explanations without overwhelming the reader with technical jargon.

Criticism

While Battleships is praised for its exhaustive research and detail, some readers have noted that its density can be overwhelming for those not already familiar with naval engineering or military strategy. The depth of technical information, while a strength, may challenge readers seeking a more narrative-driven historical account. Additionally, the focus on technical and design elements may not appeal to casual readers looking for broader thematic exploration of naval warfare and history.