Crown, Covenant and Cromwell

Brief Summary

"Crown, Covenant and Cromwell" by Stuart Reid offers an in-depth look into the military aspects of the Great Civil War, focusing on the engagements in Scotland and the contributions of Scottish armies in England between 1639 and 1651. The book highlights key figures such as Alexander Leslie, James Graham, and Oliver Cromwell, examining their roles and strategies during the conflict. Reid provides a comprehensive narrative that vividly reconstructs the battles and campaigns, offering insights into both the tactics employed and the soldiers who fought in them.

Main Themes and Topics

The book primarily delves into the military history of the last Anglo-Scottish War, with Reid meticulously analyzing the various battles and campaigns that took place. A significant theme is the examination of military leaders and their strategies, with a focus on figures like Alexander Leslie and Oliver Cromwell. Reid also explores the complexities of the political and military intersections of the time, although the main emphasis remains on the battlefield dynamics rather than the political backdrop. The theme of martial valor and tactical innovation is prevalent throughout the narrative.

Writing Style and Tone

Stuart Reid employs a fast-paced and authoritative narrative style in "Crown, Covenant and Cromwell." His writing is detailed and rich with historical insights, making intricate military maneuvers and battlefield tactics accessible to both historians and general readers. The tone is one of respect and admiration for the historical figures and events described, and Reid's expertise in Scottish military history shines through, providing a well-researched and comprehensive account.

Criticism

While Reid’s narrative is robust and detailed, some readers might find the heavy focus on military aspects over political contexts to be a limiting factor. Those looking for a broader exploration of the civil war's political intricacies might find the book's focus on battles and campaigns too narrow. Additionally, the detailed descriptions of military tactics and movements may be overwhelming for readers not familiar with military terminology.