Death in the Doldrums

Brief Summary

Death in the Doldrums by Bernard Edwards is a riveting historical account that explores the operations of the formidable U-Cruisers during World War II. Specifically, the book delves into the strategic deployment of the Type IX U-Cruisers, their extended range, and the significant impact they had on Allied naval operations around the Gulf of Guinea in 1942 and 1943. With the closing of the Suez Canal, the Allied forces had to reroute through the Cape of Good Hope, making them vulnerable to these efficient maritime predators. The book prominently features the exploits of U-68 and U-505, which proved to be much more than the mere nuisances the Allies expected.

Main Themes and Topics

One of the central themes of Death in the Doldrums is the element of surprise and underestimation in warfare. Edwards effectively demonstrates how the Allies initially dismissed the U-Cruisers as negligible threats, only to later recognize the significant damage they could inflict on wartime logistics and shipping routes. The book also addresses the strategic shift in naval warfare tactics, highlighting the Allies' need to adapt quickly to the evolving threats posed by the U-Cruisers.

Furthermore, Edwards offers an in-depth examination of the broader implications of naval warfare during World War II, focusing on the psychological and logistical ramifications faced by the Allied forces. The narrative reflects on the challenges of organizing convoys between the UK and Freetown, emphasizing the transition from relative safety to a perilous environment.

Writing Style and Tone

Bernard Edwards employs a methodical and detailed writing style that reflects his background as a naval historian. The tone is factual and authoritative, providing a well-researched account of the events described. Edwards' meticulous attention to detail ensures that readers gain a comprehensive understanding of the strategic decisions and naval operations of the time. Despite the dense subject matter, the narrative remains accessible, weaving technical details with engaging storytelling to maintain the reader's interest throughout.

Criticism

While Death in the Doldrums is praised for its thorough research and historical accuracy, some readers may find the book to be overly technical and dense. The extensive focus on naval operations and strategic details might not appeal to readers without a strong interest in military history. Additionally, the narrative sometimes lacks the personal stories of individuals involved, which could have added a human element to the historical events described.