For Country and Corps

Brief Summary

For Country and Corps by Gail B Shisler is a compelling biography of Oliver P. Smith, a notable figure in the history of the United States Marine Corps. Smith's combat acumen shone through in some of the fiercest battles of the 20th century, including Peleliu and Okinawa, and later as the commander of the 1st Marine Division during pivotal moments in the Korean War, such as the Inchon landing, the recapture of Seoul, and the Chosin Reservoir breakout. Written by his granddaughter, the book draws extensively from personal letters and interviews, offering a unique insider perspective on Smith’s life and career. The narrative also revisits Smith’s relationships within military circles, challenging previous accounts and offering fresh insights into the Marine Corps' postwar narratives.

Main Themes and Topics

The book delves deeply into themes of leadership and moral courage, painting a portrait of Oliver P. Smith as not just a military strategist but a man of great integrity and intellectual prowess. Shisler explores the dynamics of military relationships, particularly Smith's interactions with Army superiors and his peers within the Marine Corps. Through these interactions, the book highlights the strategic and often contentious nature of military command and the personal qualities that allowed Smith to navigate these challenges successfully. Another significant theme is the resilience of the Marine Corps itself, underscored by Smith’s role in the Corps' evolving strategies and its battle for postwar relevance and survival.

Writing Style and Tone

Gail Shisler adopts a tone that is both scholarly and personal, reflecting her unique position as both a historian and a family member. Her writing style combines rigorous historical research with an intimate narrative voice, providing depth and authenticity to the biography. Shisler's use of family letters and interviews adds a personal dimension to the book, enriching the historical context with personal anecdotes and reflections. This approach allows readers to engage with the content on multiple levels, appreciating both Smith's public legacy and his private persona.

Awards and Recognition

For Country and Corps has been recognized for its in-depth research and contribution to military biography literature. The book stands out for offering new insights into a well-documented period of military history, largely due to Shisler's access to family-held documents and her meticulous research. While specific awards may not be widely publicized, the book’s reception among historians and military enthusiasts highlights its significance in adding a nuanced perspective to the understanding of Marine Corps history and Oliver P. Smith's influential role.

Criticism

Some critics have noted that the book's close proximity to its subject due to the author’s familial connection may lead to a somewhat biased portrayal of Oliver P. Smith. However, others argue that this very connection is what lends the biography its strength, offering nuanced insights that might have been inaccessible otherwise. The balance between personal narrative and historical analysis is a point of contention, with some readers preferring a more detached historical account.