March to Massacre
by William H. Guthman
"A History of the First Seven Years of the United States Army, 1784-1791"
Popularity
3.82 / 5
* A book's popularity is determined by how it compares to all other books on this website.
Where to buy?
Buy from Amazon* If you buy this book through the link above, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.
March to Massacre by William H. Guthman
Details
War:
American Revolutionary War
Perspective:
Infantry
Military Unit:
US Army
True Story:
Yes
Biography:
No
Region:
North America
Page Count:
296
Published Date:
1974
ISBN13:
9780070252974
Description
Brief Summary
March to Massacre by William H. Guthman offers a detailed chronicle of the early years of the United States' attempts to secure and protect the Northwest Territory. Covering the period from 1784 to 1791, Guthman explores the challenges faced by the first Federal Army amid their ill-equipped and ultimately unsuccessful efforts to maintain control over this expansive area. The book delves into the political and military struggles of this era, providing extensive insights into the strategies and mishaps that characterized these early military campaigns.
Main Themes and Topics
Guthman’s work predominantly explores the themes of military strategy, federal government challenges, and territorial expansion. The book highlights the complexities and hardships endured by the fledgling Federal Army as they grappled with inadequate supplies, untrained personnel, and a lack of understanding of the terrain. Additionally, it focuses on the broader implications of nation-building and the federal government’s role in executing its policies in newly-acquired lands, reflecting on both the successes and failures of early American expansionist efforts.
Writing Style and Tone
Guthman's writing style in March to Massacre is informative and meticulously detailed, engaging readers who have an interest in early American history. The tone is academic yet accessible, making complex historical and military concepts understandable to a broader audience. Guthman balances factual reporting with descriptive narratives, transporting readers to the time period with vivid depictions of the arduous conditions faced by the troops. His commitment to historical accuracy and thorough research is evident throughout the text.
Criticism
Some readers have noted that the book’s dense focus on military strategy and exhaustive details can at times be overwhelming. The comprehensive nature of Guthman's research, while thorough, might not appeal to those looking for a narrative-driven historical account. Instead, it serves as an in-depth resource for history buffs and scholars who appreciate the granularity of military and governmental chronicles.