The Bolsheviks and the Red Army 1918-1921
by Francesco Benvenuti
Popularity
1.67 / 5
* A book's popularity is determined by how it compares to all other books on this website.
Where to buy?
Buy from Amazon* If you buy this book through the link above, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.
The Bolsheviks and the Red Army 1918-1921 by Francesco Benvenuti
Details
War:
Russian Civil War
Perspective:
Commanders
Military Unit:
Red Army
True Story:
Yes
Biography:
No
Region:
Europe
Page Count:
282
Published Date:
1988
ISBN13:
9780521257718
Description
Brief Summary
The Bolsheviks and the Red Army 1918-1921 by Francesco Benvenuti explores an often overlooked dimension of Soviet history – the military agency during the inter-war period, focusing on the politics within the Red Army amid the turmoil of the Civil War. Benvenuti provides an in-depth analysis, challenging previous assumptions about Stalinism's origins and the internal opposition within the Bolshevik party. The book offers a nuanced account of how the military dynamics and political tensions between Trotsky's military pursuits and party interests played a key role in shaping Soviet governance post-revolution.
Main Themes and Topics
One of the main themes of Benvenuti's work is the political dimension of the Red Army's emergence and its impact on the broader Soviet state apparatus. The book delves into the internal conflicts within the Bolshevik party, particularly highlighting Trotsky's contentious role in the militarization of Soviet society. The author also examines the tension between the technocratic approaches and the party's ideological rigidity, offering insights into the foundations of later Soviet policies.
Writing Style and Tone
Francesco Benvenuti adopts a scholarly yet engaging writing style that is accessible to both historians and general readers interested in Soviet history. His tone is analytical, providing a well-researched perspective supported by substantial historical evidence and contemporary accounts. The narrative is carefully structured, guiding the reader through complex political and military interactions without overwhelming them with technical jargon.
Criticism
Some readers might find Benvenuti's focus on the political over the operational activities of the Red Army a limitation, especially for those seeking a broader military history of the Civil War period. Additionally, while the book challenges existing narratives about Stalinism's origins, some might argue that it could delve deeper into the specific consequences of these military-politics dynamics in later Soviet policies.
