The Evil Necessity

Brief Summary

The Evil Necessity by Denver Brunsman explores the crucial yet controversial role of naval impressment in Britain's rise as a global power during the eighteenth century. Impressment, or the forcible recruitment of seamen into the Royal Navy, is positioned as a necessary evil that not only sustained British naval supremacy but also had profound consequences on Atlantic seafarers and their communities. Brunsman sheds light on the experiences of those affected—approximately 250,000 mariners who were pressed into service, with fatal outcomes for many. Through a careful examination of historical documents like ships’ logs, personal letters, and political texts, he illustrates the widespread impact of impressment and its contribution to significant historical events such as the American Revolution and the War of 1812.

Main Themes and Topics

The main themes of The Evil Necessity revolve around the implications of naval impressment as a driving force behind Britain's military and imperial dominance. Brunsman delves into the harsh realities faced by impressed mariners and highlights impressment's role in broader socio-political contexts, serving as a linchpin for maritime defense and a catalyst for American revolutionary sentiments. The book also underscores the ethical and moral dilemmas surrounding impressment, reflecting on its necessity versus its human cost.

Writing Style and Tone

Denver Brunsman’s writing is both scholarly and engaging, marked by an accurate and vivid depiction of historical events. His narrative style effectively balances detailed historical analysis with compelling storytelling, making the complex topic accessible to both academic and non-academic audiences. Through meticulously researched anecdotes and personal narratives, Brunsman personalizes the historical actors, bringing the eighteenth-century maritime world to life.

Awards and Recognition

The Evil Necessity has been recognized as an outstanding contribution to eighteenth-century studies, being awarded the Walker Cowen Memorial Prize. This accolade is a testament to Brunsman's thorough research and insightful analysis in addressing the complex history of naval impressment.

Criticism

While The Evil Necessity is widely praised for its detailed research and engaging prose, some readers may find the dense historical content challenging. The extensive focus on maritime history and the intricate details of naval logistics might not appeal to all audiences, particularly those less inclined towards military history. However, these elements are integral to Brunsman’s comprehensive depiction of the era.