The "Good Soldier" on Trial
by Stjepan Gabriel Meštrović
"A Sociological Study of Misconduct by the U.S. Military Pertaining to Operation Iron Triangle, Iraq"
Popularity
3.34 / 5
* A book's popularity is determined by how it compares to all other books on this website.
Where to buy?
Buy from Amazon* If you buy this book through the link above, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.
The "Good Soldier" on Trial by Stjepan Gabriel Meštrović
Details
War:
Iraq War
Perspective:
Researcher
Military Unit:
US Army
True Story:
Yes
Biography:
No
Region:
Middle East
Page Count:
294
Published Date:
2009
ISBN13:
9780875867410
Description
Brief Summary (no spoilers)
"The 'Good Soldier' on Trial" by Stjepan Gabriel Meštrović offers a gripping exploration of the complexities surrounding military justice, rules of engagement, and ethical dilemmas faced by soldiers. The book centers around the controversial court case of Sergeant Michael Leahy, a decorated soldier who was sentenced to life imprisonment in 2009 despite his military achievements. As an expert witness, Meštrović delves into the inconsistencies and systemic shortcomings within the military justice system, presenting a compelling narrative that questions the distinction between criminal actions and acts of heroism.
Main Themes and Topics
At its core, the book scrutinizes the dichotomy between heroism and criminality in the context of war. Meštrović challenges the traditional narratives that surround military conduct, particularly focusing on how these narratives affect the lives of soldiers. The book examines the systemic issues within military justice, including the flawed rules of engagement that often leave soldiers in legal jeopardy for actions taken in the heat of battle. Additionally, it raises important questions about moral responsibility and the often-blurred line between duty and wrongdoing.
Writing Style and Tone
Meštrović employs a straightforward and analytical writing style, allowing readers to engage with complex legal and ethical issues without getting bogged down in jargon. The tone is both critical and empathetic, reflecting the author's nuanced understanding of the subject. By integrating case studies and his personal experience as an expert witness, Meštrović provides a balanced perspective that is both informative and thought-provoking.
Criticism
While "The 'Good Soldier' on Trial" has been praised for its insightful analysis, some critics argue that the book could benefit from a more diverse range of case studies beyond the focus on Sergeant Leahy. Others feel that the book's heavy focus on legal intricacies may not resonate with readers who are less familiar with military law. Despite these criticisms, the book's thorough examination of its central case and the broader implications for military justice make it a significant contribution to discussions about ethics and accountability in warfare.
