Wampum Denied
by Sandy Antal
"Procter's War of 1812"
Popularity
0.85 / 5
* A book's popularity is determined by how it compares to all other books on this website.
Where to buy?
Buy from Amazon* If you buy this book through the link above, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Wampum Denied by Sandy Antal
Details
War:
War of 1812
Perspective:
Commanders
Military Unit:
British Army
True Story:
Yes
Biography:
No
Region:
North America
Page Count:
472
Published Date:
1997
ISBN13:
9780886293185
Description
Brief Summary
"Wampum Denied" by Sandy Antal presents a formative history of the war on the Detroit frontier during 1812-13, focusing on significant figures like Procter, Tecumseh, and Brock. The book delves into the various aspirations and motivations behind the war efforts, examining both the heroic and mundane elements of the conflict. Antal’s work shines a spotlight on the often overlooked Canadian/British/Native side of the war, challenging the predominantly American perspective.
Main Themes and Topics
The core themes of "Wampum Denied" revolve around the complex web of motives that defined the 1812-13 conflict on the Detroit frontier. Antal adeptly explores Native and national aspirations, colonial interests, and the territorial ambitions that fueled the war. Through careful reconstruction, the book reveals the larger-than-life nature of the campaigns conducted by figures like Henry Procter, Tecumseh, and Isaac Brock. The examination of the military strategies showcases the multidimensionality of the conflict, bringing forth a nuanced understanding of the allied efforts and their near success, despite their eventual spectacular failure.
Writing Style and Tone
Sandy Antal’s writing in "Wampum Denied" is meticulous and richly detailed, reflecting deep scholarly research. The tone is analytical and balanced, steering clear of romanticization while providing a comprehensive account of the events. Antal's narrative weaves together various perspectives, contributing to a textured understanding of a complex historical episode. The approach is both informative and engaging, making the book accessible to both academics and general readers interested in history.
Criticism
While "Wampum Denied" is praised for its detailed research and fresh perspective, some readers might find the dense historical analysis challenging. The focus on minute details, while enriching for some, may be overwhelming for those seeking a more straightforward narrative of the conflict. Nonetheless, Antal's commitment to presenting a multifaceted historical account is evident, even if it demands a somewhat more engaged reading experience.
