A Peculiar Crusade

Brief Summary

A Peculiar Crusade by James J. Weingartner delves into the captivating story of Willis M. Everett, Jr., an Atlanta attorney who put his reputation on the line to defend members of the Nazi SS. These individuals were accused of a horrific war crime involving the murder of American prisoners of war. The book explores the complexities of Everett's motivations, partly rooted in controversial antisemitic views and partly from his strange admiration for a key German defendant. The narrative weaves together elements of legal drama and historical intrigue, providing a well-rounded view of an unusual and often unsettling chapter of post-war history.

Main Themes and Topics

One of the central themes of A Peculiar Crusade is the moral ambiguity that often accompanies legal defense in the aftermath of wartime atrocities. Weingartner meticulously examines the moral and ethical dilemmas faced by Everett as he balances his professional duties with his personal beliefs. The book also touches on themes of antisemitism and its influence on legal and social structures in post-war America. A peculiar focus is placed on the unexpected relationship between Everett and his German defendant, offering insights into how personal connections can skew judgment and complicate justice.

Writing Style and Tone

James J. Weingartner employs a scholarly yet accessible writing style that is engaging and informative. His tone is objective, as expected from a historian, but he manages to convey the dramatic tension and ethical weight of the events he describes. The inclusion of historical photographs enhances the narrative, providing a visual context that complements the detailed prose. Weingartner's background as a history professor lends authority to the narrative, ensuring that the book is as educational as it is intriguing.