A Plain Sailorman in China

Brief Summary

A Plain Sailorman in China by Bruce Swanson is an engaging biography that chronicles the life of Cdr. Irvin Van Gorder Gillis, a remarkable individual whose career spanned several decades in the U.S. Navy and culminated in a unique post-naval career as a collector of rare Chinese manuscripts. The book elucidates both his exceptional family history and career milestones, offering a vivid depiction of historical events through the eyes of a naval officer. Gillis's adventures and contributions are set against the backdrop of significant global military and political developments from the late 19th century into the early 20th century.

Main Themes and Topics

The book delves into various themes such as military honor, international diplomacy, cultural exchange, and the intricacies of naval warfare during transitional periods in history. It highlights the sense of duty and courage exemplified by Gillis, particularly during critical assignments in the Spanish-American War and as a naval attaché in Asia. A prominent theme in the book is the intersection of American and Asian cultures, explored through Gillis's marriage to a Chinese princess and his work with rare Chinese manuscripts, reflecting a merging of personal and professional spheres.

Writing Style and Tone

Swanson writes with an authoritative yet accessible style, offering meticulous details about naval procedures and familial history without overwhelming the reader. The tone of the book is respectful and admiring, capturing the essence of Gillis's character and his myriad accomplishments. Swanson's prose effectively intertwines historical context with personal narrative, making complex events and Gillis’s life journey understandable to both military enthusiasts and general readers.

Criticism

While the book is a comprehensive account of Gillis's life and times, some readers may find the extensive details about naval operations and protocols a bit dense. Additionally, the focus on military aspects might overshadow other potential areas of Gillis's life that could have been explored further, such as his personal relationships and deeper insights into his life in China beyond his professional endeavors.