Bomber Harris

Brief Summary

Bomber Harris by John Grehan delves into the controversial bombing campaigns conducted by Bomber Command against Germany during World War II. The book focuses on the strategies employed by Sir Arthur Harris, whose "area" bombing tactics aimed to break the morale of the German population by targeting entire cities. The book includes insights from Harris' detailed despatches and explores the reasons these documents were withheld by the government for many years. This detailed account sheds light on the ethical and strategic implications of the bombing operations that brought Germany to the brink of collapse.

Main Themes and Topics

The central theme of the book is the morally ambiguous nature of warfare, specifically the use of area bombing as a psychological weapon during World War II. Grehan explores the fine line between military necessity and humanitarian concern. By presenting Harris' despatches in their entirety, the book provides readers with a comprehensive understanding of the strategic motivations and ethical considerations underlying one of the most divisive military operations of the 20th century. Another pertinent topic is the political controversy surrounding the censorship of Harris' despatches, highlighting the tension between military strategy and public perception.

Writing Style and Tone

John Grehan's writing is meticulous and informative, offering a detailed and well-researched narrative that is both engaging and enlightening. The tone of the book is balanced, striving to present multiple perspectives on a complex historical issue without alienating any particular viewpoint. Grehan's style is accessible, allowing readers to engage with the dense historical material in a coherent and comprehensive manner. Through extensive research and a clear presentation, the book succeeds in bringing to life the historical context and strategic intricacies of Bomber Command's operations.

Criticism

While Bomber Harris is praised for its in-depth documentation and historical accuracy, some readers may find it challenging due to the dense nature of military despatches and strategic analysis. The book's focus on providing a comprehensive account of Harris' reports might come across as overly detailed for those seeking a more general overview of World War II operations. Additionally, some critics argue that the book could have benefited from a deeper exploration of the human impact of the bombing campaigns on civilian populations, thus offering a more rounded perspective on the ethical implications of such actions.