Hate the War Honor the Soldier

Brief Summary

Hate the War Honor the Soldier by Robert M. Givens is a deeply personal narrative capturing the tumultuous experiences of the author during the Vietnam War. The book takes readers through Givens' journey from being a university official who believed his education and status might shield him from the draft, to becoming an infantry soldier in the midst of an unpopular conflict. The story reflects on Givens' transformation, shaped by the harsh realities of war, and concludes with his return home to a society engulfed in protests. The narrative also touches upon his eventual spiritual awakening and ongoing quest for healing.

Main Themes and Topics

One of the central themes in Hate the War Honor the Soldier is the transformation of personal beliefs under the pressure of life-changing experiences. Givens explores how his initial sense of intellectual superiority and entitlement was dismantled by his time on the front lines in Vietnam. The book also delves into themes of disillusionment, camaraderie among soldiers, and the societal divides between warfront experiences and the anti-war sentiment back home. A significant portion of the narrative is devoted to the reconciliation of these divides and the rediscovery of personal faith.

Writing Style and Tone

Givens writes with a reflective and honest tone, providing readers with an introspective view of his internal struggles and the external challenges he faced during the war. The writing is poignant and accessible, drawing on vivid descriptions to bring the raw and often harrowing realities of war to life. Givens opts for a straightforward narrative style that effectively conveys the emotional depth of his experiences without unnecessary embellishment.

Criticism

Some readers may find the book’s focus on personal transformation and religious awakening less compelling if they are primarily interested in military history or strategy. The introspective nature of the narrative may not appeal to those seeking an objective or broader historical account of the Vietnam War. However, Givens' personal story provides a unique and individual perspective that can offer valuable insights into the personal impacts of war.