Hispanic Americans in the Civil War

Brief Summary

"Hispanic Americans in the Civil War" by A J Schenkman brings to light the often overlooked contributions of Hispanic Americans during a pivotal period in United States history. Through detailed accounts of individuals like Loreta Janeta Velázquez, who disguised herself as a male soldier to join the battlefield, and Philip Bazaar, a Medal of Honor recipient for his bravery, Schenkman illustrates the diverse roles that these individuals played. The book delves into the exploits of figures such as Union Admiral David Farragut, highlighting their significant impacts and personal stories. Schenkman’s work is not only a historical record but also a tribute to the bravery and contributions of Hispanic Americans in the Civil War.

Main Themes and Topics

The central theme of the book is the acknowledgment and celebration of the contributions of Hispanic Americans in the Civil War. Schenkman explores themes of identity, bravery, and perseverance, spotlighting stories of individuals who defied societal norms and personal circumstances to make a significant impact. The book also explores themes of recognition and the importance of documenting the stories of marginalized groups within historical narratives. By uncovering these forgotten fighters and unknown exploits, Schenkman challenges the traditional narrative of the Civil War and enriches the reader's understanding of American history.

Writing Style and Tone

A J Schenkman employs a narrative style that is both engaging and informative, making complex historical events accessible to a broad audience. The tone of the book is respectful and celebratory, aiming to honor the individuals it profiles without resorting to romanticization. Schenkman's use of vivid storytelling brings the historical figures to life while maintaining historical accuracy. The clear and organized structure allows readers to follow the diverse experiences of these Hispanic Americans throughout the Civil War seamlessly.

Criticism

While "Hispanic Americans in the Civil War" offers a valuable contribution to Civil War history, some readers may find that the focus on individual stories comes at the cost of a broader contextual analysis. The book primarily concentrates on personal anecdotes and specific exploits, which, while compelling, might leave readers wishing for a deeper exploration of the larger socio-political dynamics affecting Hispanic Americans during this era. Additionally, some readers may desire more information on the post-war lives and legacies of the figures highlighted in the book.