How America Won World War I

Brief Summary

"How America Won World War I" by Alan Axelrod presents a compelling narrative about the pivotal role played by the American infantry in the Allied victory during World War I. Rather than delving into the varying perspectives of other Allied forces like Britain and France, the book emphasizes the acknowledgment from Germany's own military leadership, particularly Paul von Hindenburg, who credited the American forces with delivering the decisive blow. This book provides an engaging recount of the military strategies and critical battles, particularly the action in the Argonne, that led to the Allied success.

Main Themes and Topics

One of the central themes of the book is the critical impact of American forces in World War I. Axelrod explores the dynamic changes that occurred with the entry of U.S. troops into the war and how they were instrumental in turning the tide against Germany. A significant focus is placed on the American infantry's efforts in the Meuse-Argonne Offensive, elucidating how these soldiers' bravery and strategic maneuvers were crucial in securing victory. The book delves into the broader implications of this victory not just for the military outcome, but also for America's emerging role on the world stage.

Writing Style and Tone

Alan Axelrod's writing style is informative and engaging, striking a balance between scholarly analysis and accessible narrative. His tone is authoritative, effectively supported by historical evidence and detailed accounts of military strategies and engagements. Axelrod's meticulous research underpins his narrative, allowing him to present a focused perspective on how American forces shaped the outcome of World War I.

Criticism

While "How America Won World War I" is lauded for its thorough research and compelling narrative, some readers might find the perspective somewhat narrow as it primarily highlights the contribution of American forces. The focus on the American role might overshadow the contributions of other Allied powers, which could be perceived as a limited view of the collaborative efforts that ultimately led to victory. However, given the book's intent to spotlight the U.S. infantry, Axelrod achieves this aim with precision.