Kipling's Choice

Brief Summary

Kipling's Choice by Geert Spillebeen is a compelling historical novel that brings to life the story of John Kipling, the son of renowned British author Rudyard Kipling. The narrative unfolds during World War I, following John's journey from a life of privilege to the harsh realities of the battlefield. Guided by his father's influence, John, who suffers from poor eyesight, secures a commission in the army. This choice, driven by the desire to uphold his family legacy, quickly turns into a struggle for survival in the trenches of war. Spillebeen's account highlights the personal sacrifices and broader themes of loss and the futility of war.

Main Themes and Topics

The novel delves deeply into the themes of duty, sacrifice, and the haunting impact of war. It explores the generational expectations between fathers and sons, exemplified by Rudyard Kipling's determination to see his son serve in the military, despite the obvious dangers. Spillebeen poignantly portrays the stark contrast between the romantic ideals of war held by those at home and the brutal reality faced by soldiers on the front line. Additionally, the book touches upon the broader issue of the needless carnage and loss that war inflicts upon individuals and families.

Writing Style and Tone

Geert Spillebeen employs a narrative style that is both sensitive and evocative, capturing the emotional and psychological landscape of his characters with precision. The prose is imbued with a sense of immediacy and tension, reflecting the dire circumstances of war. The tone is somber and reflective, offering readers a chance to ponder the deep personal and collective consequences of warfare. Spillebeen's ability to weave historical fact with fiction makes the story both educational and engaging, showing a clear respect for the historical context while delivering a deeply personal narrative.

Criticism

While Kipling's Choice has been praised for its emotional depth and historical accuracy, some readers might find the pace of the novel slow, particularly in the early chapters where the groundwork of John's background and family dynamics is established. Additionally, although the novel provides a poignant depiction of war, some may feel the focus is overly narrow, primarily concentrating on John's experiences without offering a wider view of the conflict.