Madison County, New York Soldiers in the War of 1812

Brief Summary

Madison County, New York Soldiers in the War of 1812 by William H. Tuttle offers a meticulously compiled list of veterans from Madison County who served in the War of 1812. This collection, once a private file created by Tuttle in his role as the Madison County Historian, draws from various historical sources to provide a comprehensive registry. The entries are orderly arranged by surname, making it an accessible reference for researchers and local historians. The book serves as both a tribute and a resource for anyone interested in learning more about the contributions of these soldiers during a pivotal time in American history.

Main Themes and Topics

The central theme of Tuttle's book is historical documentation and civilian contribution to military efforts. By including records such as pensions, claims for expenses on clothing and equipment, and local resources like cemetery inscriptions and newspaper items, Tuttle showcases the individual stories and sacrifices of soldiers from Madison County. The book emphasizes the importance of preserving local histories and personal stories, illustrating how these can enrich our understanding of broader historical events such as the War of 1812.

Writing Style and Tone

Tuttle's writing style in this volume is factual and straightforward, fitting the book's purpose as a historical reference. The tone is objective, with an emphasis on presenting accurate data rather than narrative storytelling. The alphabetical listing and the structured layout make the book a practical tool for researchers and genealogists interested in exploring their ancestry related to this particular era. The inclusion of a bibliography further aids in guiding readers to additional resources and references.

Criticism

While the book is an invaluable resource for those specifically interested in Madison County's participation in the War of 1812, its scope is rather narrow, which may limit its appeal to a broader audience. The alphabetical arrangement, although useful, may not engage readers looking for a more contextual or narrative-driven account of the period. Additionally, the book's focus on data collection over storytelling means that readers looking for personal stories or in-depth analysis of the war's impact might find it lacking.