Pickett's Men

Brief Summary

Pickett's Men by Walter Harrison provides an in-depth history of Pickett's division, one of the notable units in the Army of Northern Virginia during the American Civil War. Written by the division's inspector general, this book offers a firsthand account of the gallantry displayed by the men at famous battles including Seven Pines, Seven Days, Fredericksburg, and Gettysburg. Originally published in 1870, this work precedes the narratives influenced by the Lost Cause ideology, offering a more unembellished perspective.

Main Themes and Topics

The core theme of Pickett's Men revolves around the valor and sacrifices of the Confederate soldiers within Pickett's division. Harrison seeks to document and honor the heroism displayed during key battles, while providing a candid take on the leadership strategies deployed during the Civil War. The book illustrates the humanity and endurance of the soldiers, as well as their unwavering dedication to their cause, despite the harrowing circumstances they faced. In addition, Harrison's willingness to critique generals and politicians, including an insightful analysis of figures like Pickett and Robert E. Lee, provides a balanced and often enriching perspective on their military decisions and leadership styles.

Writing Style and Tone

Walter Harrison's writing style is both vivid and meticulous, capturing the deeply human aspects of war while maintaining historical accuracy. The tone is characterized by a sense of respect and admiration for the soldiers' gallantry, combined with a fair and sometimes critical evaluation of military leaders. By providing detailed accounts from an insider's perspective, Harrison lends a degree of authenticity to his narratives, making it an engaging read for Civil War enthusiasts and scholars alike.

Criticism

One aspect of Pickett's Men that may draw criticism is its focus on the Confederate perspective, which could be seen as a limitation in understanding the broader implications and viewpoints of the Civil War. While Harrison is forthright in his praise for the men's bravery, readers may find the narrative less comprehensive in terms of exploring the moral and political dimensions of the conflict. However, Harrison's role as an inspector general within the division lends authority to his account and contributes valuable firsthand insights to Civil War literature.