Riding with Custer

Brief Summary (no spoilers)

"Riding with Custer" by James Harvey Kidd is an engrossing account of cavalry operations during the American Civil War, as experienced by Captain Kidd himself. This memoir takes readers through Kidd's personal journey from raising his company to engaging in numerous battles alongside the legendary General George Armstrong Custer. The book vividly illustrates the strategic importance of cavalry and offers insights into various famous battles, including Gettysburg and Cedar Creek. Kidd provides a firsthand perspective of the chaotic and exhilarating life of a soldier, underscoring the challenges posed by unpredictable weather and terrain, and the camaraderie among troops.

Main Themes and Topics

One of the key themes in "Riding with Custer" is the tactical role and significance of cavalry in the Union Army during the Civil War. Kidd emphasizes the strategic mobility and impact of cavalry units on the battlefield. The book also explores leadership and valor, highlighting Kidd's ascent to colonel and his eventual succession from Custer in commanding the Michigan Brigade. Through various recollections, Kidd examines the camaraderie and resilience necessary in warfare, painting a detailed picture of the soldier's experience while underlining the emotional and physical demands of battle.

Writing Style and Tone

James Harvey Kidd's writing style in "Riding with Custer" is vivid and engaging, offering a rich and detailed narrative of his experiences. His prose brings to life the intensity of battle and the stark realities of war, balancing technical military detail with personal anecdotes and reflections. The tone is one of respect for both his comrades and adversaries, filled with a sense of duty and honor. Kidd’s memoirs are noted for their clarity and the indelible impressions they leave, making it accessible and compelling for both history enthusiasts and general readers.

Criticism

While "Riding with Custer" provides an invaluable eyewitness account of the Civil War, some readers may find Kidd’s perspective heavily influenced by his deep admiration for Custer and his experiences in the Union cavalry. This bias might lead to a less critical portrayal of some events or figures. Additionally, as with many historical memoirs, the book contains the inherent limitations of personal perspective, which might omit broader contextual analyses of the war's political and social implications. Nonetheless, the book remains a significant historical document for those interested in Civil War history and military strategy.