Sardar: US State Department deployment October 13, 2009-January 5, 2011

Brief Summary

"Sardar: US State Department deployment October 13, 2009-January 5, 2011" by Abdullah Sharif is a reflective memoir that chronicles Sharif's experience as a US diplomat in Afghanistan. Through a series of nineteen missives, Sharif provides personal insights and commentary on his time during his first civilian deployment with the Departments of State and Defense. The book intertwines his Afghan heritage and American diplomatic perspective, offering a nuanced view of the reconstruction efforts and the complex socio-political landscape in Afghanistan during an era of conflict and transformation.

Main Themes and Topics

The primary themes of "Sardar" revolve around the challenges and intricacies of international diplomacy, cultural integration, and conflict resolution. Sharif delves into the sociopolitical dynamics of Afghanistan, critiquing the effectiveness of US reconstruction strategies and highlighting the frequent misunderstandings that arise from differing ideologies and cultural barriers. The book also touches upon themes of identity and belonging, as Sharif revisits his homeland under vastly changed circumstances and reflects on his dual identity as an Afghan-American.

Writing Style and Tone

Abdullah Sharif's writing style in "Sardar" is both analytical and introspective, blending factual reportage with personal reflection. His tone is candid and insightful, providing readers with a balanced view of the events he narrates. Through his missives, Sharif manages to convey the complexities of his diplomatic mission with clarity and depth, engaging the reader with both historical context and personal anecdotes. His narrative is accessible yet rich in detail, making it a compelling read for those interested in foreign policy and international relations.

Criticism

While "Sardar" offers many insightful observations, it may be critiqued for its potential lack of broader context outside of Sharif's personal experiences. Some readers might find the focus on missives limiting in providing a more comprehensive analysis. Additionally, those seeking a purely academic or heavily researched account of US involvement in Afghanistan might find the book's personal narrative style less rigorous in its exploration.