Should Be Soldiers

Brief Summary

Should Be Soldiers by John Benton is a captivating collection of stories featuring an American protagonist's journey back to Europe, specifically the serene coastal regions of Ireland. The book explores the profound differences in lifestyle and societal structures between those who remained in Ireland during the Great Famine and their descendants, and those who emigrated to the United States over the last two centuries. Each tale is a standalone narrative that delves into themes of identity, cultural contrast, and the quest for meaning in simpler surroundings.

Main Themes and Topics

The central themes of Should Be Soldiers revolve around identity, migration, and cultural dislocation. Benton contrasts the pastoral simplicity of Ireland's landscapes with the complex, often frenzied life in America. Through this juxtaposition, the narrative delves into the soul's yearning for a connection to one's roots and the inner conflict between modernity and tradition. The stories effectively highlight the emotional and societal impacts of migration during the Great Famine, reminding readers of the enduring threads of history that continue to tie emigrants to their ancestral homes.

Writing Style and Tone

John Benton employs a descriptive and reflective writing style that envelops the reader in the serene beauty of Ireland's coastlines. His narrative is both engaging and thoughtful, filled with rich, vivid imagery that evokes a strong sense of place. Benton's tone is contemplative and often nostalgic, encouraging readers to consider the deep human connections that transcend geographical boundaries. His effective use of dialogue brings authenticity to the cultural exchanges between characters, emphasizing the universal need to understand and be understood.

Criticism

While Should Be Soldiers is generally well-received for its evocative storytelling, some readers might find the pacing of the book to be somewhat slow, particularly if they are accustomed to fast-paced narratives. Benton dedicates significant time to detailed descriptions and philosophical musings, which may not resonate with those who prefer direct and action-driven plotlines. However, this deliberate pacing is an intentional stylistic choice that complements the book’s introspective themes.