The Dogs Are Eating Them Now

Brief Summary

The Dogs Are Eating Them Now by Graeme Smith is a compelling and personal account of the war in Afghanistan, illustrating the complexities of modern warfare through the eyes of a former foreign correspondent. Smith, renowned for his fearless reporting, offers an insider's perspective on how the war went dangerously wrong. The book takes readers through various facets of the conflict, from the corruption and tribal dynamics to the economic underpinnings of the drug trade. Smith's narrative is enriched by the voices of translators, guides, and ordinary citizens who played pivotal roles in uncovering the truth behind the failures of the mission.

Main Themes and Topics

The book delves deeply into themes of corruption, deceit, and the often-chaotic nature of foreign intervention in Afghanistan. Smith highlights the disconnect between the intentions of foreign troops and the ground realities faced by local citizens. He details how the mission, ostensibly aimed at fostering peace and democracy, was undermined by law enforcement corruption, tribal power struggles, and misguided military strategies. These elements are crucial to understanding the broader failure of the international community's efforts in the region.

Writing Style and Tone

Graeme Smith's writing is marked by a candid and harrowing narrative style. His firsthand experiences provide a raw and unfiltered look at the conflict, making his account both riveting and unsettling. Smith's ability to weave personal anecdotes with broader political analysis gives the book a balanced and insightful perspective. The tone is somber and reflective, capturing the gravity of the situation while underlining the human cost of war.

Awards and Recognition

Graeme Smith's work in journalism has been highly recognized, earning him multiple awards, including an Emmy for his video series "Talking with the Taliban." His book further reinforces his reputation as an authoritative voice on the insurgency, providing a critical examination of the Afghan conflict, which has been lauded for its depth and honesty.

Criticism

While The Dogs Are Eating Them Now has been praised for its insightful and brave storytelling, some critics have pointed out that the book could benefit from more detailed solutions to the problems it raises. Others have noted that its unflinching portrayal of the conflict may come across as overly pessimistic, although this is largely seen as a reflection of the grim realities documented by Smith.