The Making of a Civilian Soldier in the Civil War
by Dennis D. Urban
"The First Diary of Private William J. Mclean Along the Chesapeake and Ohio Canal and the Affair at Edwards Ferry"
Popularity
1.89 / 5
* A book's popularity is determined by how it compares to all other books on this website.
Where to buy?
Buy from Amazon* If you buy this book through the link above, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.
The Making of a Civilian Soldier in the Civil War by Dennis D. Urban
Details
War:
American Civil War
Perspective:
Infantry
True Story:
Yes
Biography:
No
Region:
North America
Page Count:
170
Published Date:
2019
ISBN13:
9781732698864
Description
Brief Summary
The Making of a Civilian Soldier in the Civil War by Dennis D. Urban is an evocative exploration of the Civil War through the lens of Pvt. William J. McLean's diary. The book begins with McLean's enlistment and follows his journey from Fairfield, NY, to Washington, DC, and beyond. McLean’s diary entries recount his experiences in the 34th New York Infantry, including notable events such as the march into Virginia and the excitement surrounding the Battle of Bull Run. This work not only transcribes McLean's diary but also delves into the early family history of McLean and describes his connections with his regimental friends and acquaintances. It paints a vivid picture of camp life and picket duty during the war while providing annotated context to enrich the historical narrative.
Main Themes and Topics
Key themes in The Making of a Civilian Soldier in the Civil War include the transformation of ordinary civilians into soldiers, the camaraderie and struggles within the ranks, and the personal sacrifices made during the Civil War. Urban's work also sheds light on the historical significance of the 34th New York Infantry and the intricate dynamics of antebellum society, especially focusing on Herkimer County and the town of Fairfield. The book offers a detailed account of military life, from mundane routines to startling incidents of combat, enriching our understanding of this turbulent era.
Writing Style and Tone
Dennis D. Urban employs a meticulous and scholarly writing style that is both engaging and informative. The tone is respectful and immersive, capturing the essence of William J. McLean's experiences without romanticizing or sensationalizing the harsh realities of war. Urban’s approach is characterized by careful attention to detail, contextually enriching the diary entries with historical annotations and interpretations that provide depth to the narrative.
Criticism
While The Making of a Civilian Soldier in the Civil War is largely praised for its detailed research and comprehensive annotations, some readers may find the book's depth and focus on minute details somewhat overwhelming. The inclusion of extensive historical context, while informative, could occasionally detract from the narrative flow for those seeking a more straightforward recounting of events.
