The Making of Crusading Heroes and Villains

Brief Summary

The Making of Crusading Heroes and Villains by Mike Horswell is a thought-provoking exploration of how significant figures from the Crusades have been historically transformed into symbols of heroism and villainy. The book delves into individual case studies, examining how characters such as Tancred, Reynald of Châtillon, Conrad of Montferrat, and Queen Melisende of Jerusalem have been portrayed through the ages. It also tackles the complex legacies of Richard 'the Lionheart' and Saladin, alongside the interesting appropriation of St Louis IX by the British. This scholarly work highlights the continuous relevance and reinterpretation of crusading figures in modern times.

Main Themes and Topics

One of the book's primary themes is the intricate process through which historical figures from the Crusades are celebrated as heroes or denounced as villains. Each chapter presents a focused exploration on a particular historical figure, providing insights into how their reputations have been constructed and reconstructed over time. Horswell addresses the concept of 'crusader medievalism', shedding light on how modern perceptions and political agendas have utilized these medieval figures. These explorations underscore the enduring impact of the Crusades on cultural memory and national identity.

Writing Style and Tone

Mike Horswell employs a scholarly yet accessible writing style that caters to both academic audiences and general readers interested in historical studies. The tone is analytical and well-reasoned, providing a balanced perspective on the historical reinterpretations of crusading figures. By combining academic rigor with engaging narrative, Horswell succeeds in making complex historical analyses palatable and intriguing to a wide readership.

Criticism

While The Making of Crusading Heroes and Villains is a compelling read, some readers might find the dense scholarly approach challenging, especially those who are not well-versed in historical methodologies. The book assumes a certain level of familiarity with the Crusades, which may not be suitable for complete newcomers to the topic. Additionally, the specific focus on lesser-known figures might limit its appeal to those only interested in the most famous personalities from the Crusades.