The March Up

Main Themes and Topics

The March Up by Bing West and Major General Ray L. Smith offers a compelling account of the 22-day push to Baghdad by the 1st Marine Division during the Iraq War, focusing heavily on military strategy and combat. The book delves into the strategic objectives of the coalition forces and highlights major themes such as leadership under pressure, the realities of ground warfare, and the complexities of military decision-making in the face of uncertain and rapidly changing situations. It also provides a nuanced understanding of the chivalry and compassion shown by soldiers amidst the brutality of war, a theme encapsulated in the remarks of Major General J.N. Mattis.

Writing Style and Tone

The writing style of The March Up is both analytical and immersive, making use of precise military terminology while simultaneously capturing the chaos and intensity of combat. Bing West and Ray L. Smith's backgrounds lend the narrative an authoritative tone, enriched with their firsthand observations. Their writing is direct and unembellished, striving to convey the pragmatic truths of warfare rather than indulging in dramatization. The authors manage to balance detailed military analysis with personal anecdotes, thereby appealing to readers interested in both technical aspects of war and human stories within it.

Awards and Recognition

As of the review's data cut-off, The March Up is highly respected in military and scholarly circles and is often cited in discussions and studies about modern ground combat and military strategy. This reception is, in part, due to its unique perspective and the unparalleled access the authors had to the combat units and their various leaders during the march.

Criticism

Critics of The March Up often point to its focus on the military aspects of the operation, sometimes at the expense of broader political and social context. While the book excels in detailing the dynamics of military leadership and field strategy, some readers may find it lacking in depth regarding the larger geopolitical implications of the war. Additionally, its detailed military analysis might not appeal to a broader audience unfamiliar with military terminology and strategy.

Brief Summary (no spoilers)

The March Up chronicles the journey of the 1st Marine Division from the initial stages of U.S. operations in southern Iraq to the culminating victory in Baghdad. Unlike traditional accounts, the authors provide a behind-the-scenes look, having joined different frontline units each day. The book details not just the successes, but also the challenges and unexpected reversals faced by the troops, providing an intimate look at the human dimension of military operations. Through firsthand experience and in-depth military analysis, West and Smith reveal the strategic plan's execution on the ground, offering insights into the operational and tactical decisions that shaped the outcome of the campaign.