The Massachusetts Andrew Sharpshooters

Brief Summary (no spoilers)

"The Massachusetts Andrew Sharpshooters" by Alden C. Ellis, Jr. offers an in-depth examination of an often-overlooked group of soldiers who played a pivotal role in numerous Civil War battles. Named after Massachusetts governor John Albion Andrew, these sharpshooters were distinct for their unique long-range shooting skills. They served courageously in key battles such as Seven Pines, Antietam, Fredericksburg, Chancellorsville, and Gettysburg. Ellis meticulously chronicles their day-to-day activities, shedding light on their significant contributions and the reasons they frequently moved between units. The book also provides comprehensive historical and genealogical information for each man who served in the unit.

Main Themes and Topics

One of the central themes of "The Massachusetts Andrew Sharpshooters" is the crucial role of specialized military units in the broader context of the Civil War. The book highlights the strategic importance of sharpshooters and their adaptability to changing battlefield needs. Another key theme is the concept of state versus national allegiance, as evidenced by the decision to keep the sharpshooters under Massachusetts’ jurisdiction for state aid. The book delves into the personal and familial impacts of this decision, as well as the broader implications for military organization during the war.

Writing Style and Tone

Alden C. Ellis, Jr.'s writing is characterized by its detailed and meticulous nature. The tone is factual and informative, aiming to provide a comprehensive historical account rather than a dramatized narrative. Ellis uses a methodical approach to recount the day-to-day activities of the Massachusetts Andrew Sharpshooters, blending historical facts with genealogical data to create a vivid portrait of these soldiers. His style is accessible, making complex military strategies and formations understandable for readers with varying levels of historical knowledge.

Criticism

While "The Massachusetts Andrew Sharpshooters" is praised for its thorough research and detailed coverage, some readers may find the level of detail overwhelming. The focus on day-to-day activities and comprehensive genealogical information might appeal more to history enthusiasts and scholars than to casual readers. Additionally, the lack of a narrative-driven structure could make it a challenging read for those looking for a more conventional storytelling approach.