The Right Thing

Brief Summary

The Right Thing by Scott Waddle is a compelling narrative that delves into the tragic collision between the U.S. nuclear submarine USS Greenville and the Japanese fishing vessel Ehime Maru. The book details not only the catastrophic event but also the aftermath, focusing on Captain Scott Waddle's personal and professional turmoil as he faces the consequences of the accident. Waddle's decision to take responsibility for his actions serves as the core of this story, offering readers a profound look into themes of leadership, accountability, and integrity under extreme circumstances.

Main Themes and Topics

The book tackles several significant themes, with leadership and responsibility standing at the forefront. Captain Waddle's narrative lays bare the complex moral dilemmas faced by individuals in positions of authority, particularly in high-stakes environments like the military. The theme of accountability is explored meticulously, as Waddle confronts both public scrutiny and personal guilt. Additionally, the book addresses the concept of redemption, as Waddle seeks to reconcile his actions with his sense of duty and personal ethics. Through this narrative, readers are invited to reflect on the nature of ethical decision-making and the importance of doing the right thing, even when it comes at a great personal cost.

Writing Style and Tone

Waddle’s writing is direct and introspective, giving readers an unfiltered look into his thoughts and emotions during the incident and its aftermath. The tone of the book is candid and sincere, which effectively conveys the gravity of the situation and the weight of responsibility Captain Waddle feels. The straightforward narrative style adds to the authenticity of the account, engaging the reader with its honesty and allowing them to connect deeply with the moral and ethical considerations at play.

Criticism

Some readers may find the book's focus on Waddle's personal journey to overshadow other critical aspects of the incident, such as its impact on the families of the victims. This focus might leave readers wanting a more balanced exploration of the broader ramifications of the tragedy. Additionally, while the introspective nature of the writing provides a deep dive into Waddle's psyche, it may not cater to readers looking for a detailed technical analysis of the events leading up to the collision.