A Battle Too Far

Brief Summary

A Battle Too Far by Carole McEntee-Taylor is a captivating non-fiction work that chronicles the experiences of Rifleman Henry Taylor during World War II. Based on Taylor's diaries and recollections, as narrated to his son Lawrence, the book provides an intimate look at his journey from the 2nd Battle of El Alamein to the post-war unrest in Egypt. The story begins with Henry's participation in significant WWII battles, including his unexpected rerouting to fight in Italy and the eventual rush to Austria to counter Yugoslav forces. It also delves into the overlooked struggles of soldiers like Henry, whose battles were overshadowed by more publicized events such as D-Day. The narrative captures the relentless combat, the harsh realities of war, and the resulting mutiny spurred by ongoing civil unrest in Egypt.

Main Themes and Topics

The book explores several prominent themes, most notably the relentlessness and brutality of war, as well as the emotional and psychological toll on soldiers. A key topic is the series of battles from North Africa to Italy, focusing on the often-overlooked fronts that these soldiers faced. It highlights the irony and frustration felt by those involved, who were branded as "D Day Dodgers" despite facing severe combat conditions. The narrative also touches on the theme of mutiny, depicting how the soldiers' morale was tested to its limits due to prolonged deployment and unmet expectations upon victory.

Writing Style and Tone

Carole McEntee-Taylor's writing style is factual yet empathetic, allowing readers to deeply connect with Rifleman Henry Taylor's personal experiences. The tone is both evocative and respectful, capturing the essence of Henry's memories with clarity and depth. Through detailed recounting and rich descriptions, the author brings to life the vivid recollections of wartime struggles and soldier camaraderie. The use of first-hand diary entries and personal anecdotes provides authenticity and a compelling narrative structure that emphasizes the emotional gravity of the soldiers' experiences.

Awards and Recognition

While specific awards for A Battle Too Far are not noted, the book's importance is underscored by the Foreword provided by Lt-Gen Sir Christopher Wallace, Chairman of The Royal Green Jackets (Rifles) Museum. Additionally, its feature in The Enfield Gazette speaks to its local and historical significance, reflecting the poignant impact of Henry Taylor's story.

Criticism

The main criticism that could be inferred relates to the niche focus on a specific historical narrative that might limit its appeal to a broader audience. While meticulously documented, the book's dense historical detail might challenge readers who are unfamiliar with the intricacies of World War II battles. This specificity, however, is also a strength for enthusiasts and scholars interested in the less-documented aspects of the war.