'A Very Fine Commander'

Brief Summary

'A Very Fine Commander' by John Donovan is a captivating military memoir detailing the remarkable career of "Nap" Murray, a career soldier whose journey from peacetime service to significant wartime roles offers an intriguing glimpse into 20th-century military history. Edited by Murray's nephew, the memoir covers his experiences from early service in India, China, and Egypt, to engagements in WW2's major theaters like France, North Africa, Sicily, and Normandy. The narrative culminates in his command roles in Italy, Palestine, Catterick, and Korea. Evidently praised by Field Marshal Bernard Law Montgomery, Murray's story unravels with authenticity and restraint.

Main Themes and Topics

The book delves into several prominent themes, primarily the contrast between peacetime and wartime soldiering. Murray's career reflects the evolution of military ranks over time, serving as a poignant reminder of the unpredictable trajectory of military life. Another key theme is leadership under pressure, exemplified by Murray's rise from Major to acting Lieutenant General during WW2. This development offers insights into the responsibilities and burdens of command. The memoir also touches on the theme of honor and humility, as Murray's accounts are free from self-aggrandizement, revealing the character of a deeply respected leader.

Writing Style and Tone

The writing style of 'A Very Fine Commander' is both accessible and engaging, characterized by a straightforward narrative that avoids embellishments. The tone is respectful and reflective, capturing the nuances of Murray's experiences with a genuine and honest voice. Donovan's editorial hand is light but effective, ensuring the clarity of Murray’s recollections without overshadowing the memoir's authenticity.

Awards and Recognition

The memoir has been recognized in various military history circles for its unique perspective and detailed recounting of a mid-level officer's experiences during WW2. Publications like Pennant Magazine and HistoryOfWar.org underscore its value in offering insights into the life of a soldier who, while not among the highest-ranking generals, played a crucial role in significant historical events.

Criticism

While 'A Very Fine Commander' is praised for its authenticity and insight, some critics note that the memoir could have benefited from more personal anecdotes to provide a deeper psychological portrait of Murray. The focus on military campaigns and strategies might feel dense for readers looking for more personal reflections and emotional depth in autobiographies.