Bomber Harris - His Life and Times

Main Themes and Topics

Bomber Harris - His Life and Times by Henry Probert is a compelling examination of Sir Arthur Harris, one of the most polarizing figures in military history. The book delves into the controversial area bombing strategies employed by Harris during the Second World War, exploring the ethical and strategic dilemmas these tactics posed. Probert provides a nuanced portrayal of Harris, presenting him as a figure who commanded both respect for his leadership and criticism for the destruction wrought by his decisions.

The book also situates Harris’s decisions within the broader context of wartime policy, emphasizing the instructions he received from Churchill's administration. This contextualization is crucial to understanding the extent of Harris's autonomy and the pressures he faced, highlighting the complexities of wartime decision-making.

Writing Style and Tone

Henry Probert's writing is a balance of critical analysis and sympathetic storytelling. His thorough research is evident, as he draws upon a wealth of primary sources, including Harris's personal papers, which had not been extensively used before. The tone of the book is respectful yet probing, as Probert seeks to understand the multifaceted nature of Harris’s personality—his decisiveness and professional competence as well as his kindness and generosity. This approach allows Probert to craft a biography that is both informative and engaging, appealing to both historians and general readers interested in World War II history.

Criticism

One of the criticisms of the book is that, while Probert provides a detailed account of Harris’s military strategies and the outcomes of his decisions, some readers may feel that the book leans toward a sympathetic portrayal. The complex moral implications of Harris's area bombing tactics are discussed, but some critics argue that Probert might have mitigated the extent of their controversial nature by emphasizing the pressures Harris faced from political directives. This perspective can be seen as a potential drawback for readers seeking a more critical or detached analysis.

Brief Summary (no spoilers)

Bomber Harris - His Life and Times offers a comprehensive biography of Sir Arthur Harris, detailing his role as the head of the Royal Air Force's Bomber Command during World War II. The book examines Harris’s strategic decisions, particularly his advocacy for area bombing, and assesses the impact of his actions on both the Allied war effort and civilian populations. Through meticulous research and the use of Harris’s personal documents, Probert constructs an insightful narrative of a complex and controversial figure, providing readers with a deeper understanding of Harris’s contributions to history and the contentious legacy he left behind.