British Armour in the Second World War: The great tank scandal

Brief Summary

"British Armour in the Second World War: The Great Tank Scandal" by David Fletcher presents a detailed examination of Britain's armored forces and their development during the Second World War. The book delves into the shortcomings and challenges faced by British tank designs and the impact these had on wartime strategies and outcomes. Through meticulous research, Fletcher explores the technological and strategic decisions that led to what he describes as a scandal in British military history.

Main Themes and Topics

The central theme of the book revolves around the inadequacies and the developmental hurdles faced by British tank forces during the Second World War. Fletcher discusses how systemic issues within the British military apparatus, bureaucratic delays, and flawed decision-making processes contributed to British tanks being outclassed by their German counterparts. The book also explores the broader implications of these shortcomings on Britain's military effectiveness and strategy during the war.

Another critical theme is the analysis of specific tank models and their performance in battle. Fletcher provides a comprehensive study of how these tanks were perceived by both their operators and their adversaries, and how these perceptions affected morale and strategic tactics.

Writing Style and Tone

David Fletcher's writing style is both authoritative and accessible, drawing from his extensive expertise and background as a historian specialized in military vehicles. His tone is analytical yet engaging, as he seeks to provide a clear and detailed account of the historical events and decisions that shaped British armoured warfare. Fletcher balances scientific detail with readability, aiming to reach both military historians and general readers interested in World War II history.

Criticism

While "British Armour in the Second World War" is lauded for its thorough research and engaging narrative, some readers might find the high level of technical detail concerning tank design and engineering a bit overwhelming. Critics have pointed out that the detailed analysis of engineering decisions might appeal primarily to a niche audience with a strong interest in military technology. However, for readers keen on understanding the intricacies of wartime engineering, this detail is often seen as a strength.