Combined Special Operations In World War II

Brief Summary

Combined Special Operations In World War II by Captain James C. Nixon is an insightful historical analysis of special operations units in the European Theater during World War II. The book delves into the operational dynamics of the Dieppe Raid Force, the First Special Service Force, and the Jedburghs. By examining these units, Nixon identifies their organizational strengths and weaknesses while also critiquing the current United States combined and special operations doctrine. The study highlights the necessity for more detailed operational and tactical level strategies beyond the existing strategic guidance. Key highlights include the significance of setting clear goals, achieving unity through training, and the essential components of centralized control and communication for successful operations.

Main Themes and Topics

The core theme of Combined Special Operations In World War II is the analysis of historical special operations to draw lessons for modern military doctrine. Nixon focuses on examining the organization, training, command, and control of these units and underscores the need for explicit operational and tactical guidance in contemporary doctrine. The book also emphasizes the importance of decision-making structures and communication in achieving mission success. Another central theme is the inadequacy of relying solely on past successful operations like DESERT SHIELD/DESERT STORM as comprehensive guides for current doctrines.

Writing Style and Tone

Captain James C. Nixon employs a scholarly and analytical tone throughout the book. His writing is methodical as he systematically explores the intricate details of special operations, using historical case studies to support his claims. The text is rich with military jargon and is well-suited for readers with a keen interest in military history or defense studies. Nixon's style is direct and factual, reflecting his expertise and depth of knowledge in the subject, making it an authoritative source on World War II special operations.

Criticism

While Combined Special Operations In World War II is comprehensive in its historical analysis, some readers may find the book's dense and technical approach challenging, particularly those without a military background. The detailed focus on doctrine over narrative may not engage readers looking for personal stories or dramatic accounts of war. Additionally, the book's emphasis on improving current U.S. military doctrine might seem less relevant to an international audience interested solely in World War II history.