General Edwin Vose Sumner, USA

Brief Summary

General Edwin Vose Sumner, USA by Thomas K. Tate is a comprehensive biography of General Edwin Vose Sumner, a significant figure in the development of the U.S. Army's mounted arm. The book delves into his early life, beginning with his Boston origins in 1797, and traces his journey from abandoning a career in commerce to joining the U.S. Infantry in 1819. Sumner's influential role in the Dragoons of the 1830s, his establishment of the Cavalry School of Practice at Carlisle Barracks in Pennsylvania, and his impactful teaching of future military leaders like Richard S. Ewell are focal points of the narrative. The book also covers his distinguished service in the Mexican War, his balancing act amid the Kansas conflicts of the 1850s, and his pivotal actions in keeping California within the Union during the Civil War. Sumner's remarkable military career concluded with his command of the Second Corps until his death in 1863.

Main Themes and Topics

A central theme of the book is Sumner's significant impact on the mounted arm of the U.S. Army. The narrative sheds light on his innovative approaches and instructional prowess at the Cavalry School of Practice, highlighting his influence on prominent military figures who would later become important personalities in the Civil War. Another key topic is the nuanced exploration of Sumner's leadership during various important historical events, such as the Mexican War, the Kansas conflicts, and the preservation of California's Union allegiance. The book paints a vivid picture of the military and political landscapes of these eras and Sumner's adept navigation through complex challenges.

Writing Style and Tone

Thomas K. Tate's writing is detailed and well-researched, providing a thorough portrayal of General Sumner's life and career. The tone of the book is formal and educational, making it suitable for readers interested in military history and biographical studies. Tate's methodical approach ensures that each significant event in Sumner's life is covered with precision, while his clear narrative style makes the complex history accessible to a broad audience. The inclusion of various anecdotes and personal stories further enriches the biography, offering readers a deeper understanding of Sumner's character and motivations.

Criticism

While General Edwin Vose Sumner, USA is an informative and well-researched biography, some readers may find the level of detail to be overwhelming at times, particularly those who are not deeply versed in military history. The book's meticulous attention to military strategies and detailed accounts of lesser-known historical events, while informative, may not appeal to all casual readers. Nonetheless, for those dedicated to learning about this era and its key figures, Tate's comprehensive approach provides valuable insights into Sumner's significant contributions to American military history.