General Grant and the Rewriting of History

Brief Summary

General Grant and the Rewriting of History by Frank P. Varney offers a critical examination of Ulysses S. Grant's renowned Personal Memoirs, highlighting the discrepancies and biases that potentially distort our understanding of Civil War history. Varney scrutinizes Grant's treatment of Maj. Gen. William S. Rosecrans, among others, revealing how Grant's misstatements and fabrications impacted historical narratives. This book encourages readers to question established historical accounts and promotes a more thorough investigation of the sources that shape our understanding of the past.

Main Themes and Topics

The primary theme of General Grant and the Rewriting of History is the critical analysis of historical narratives, particularly those related to the Civil War. Frank P. Varney delves into the inaccuracies within Ulysses S. Grant's Personal Memoirs, focusing on the misrepresentations of certain military figures and events. Through rigorous examination of primary sources, Varney exposes the potential biases and manipulations present in Grant's accounts, thereby challenging readers to question the reliability of widely accepted historical "truths."

Another important topic explored in the book is the impact of Grant's alleged drinking problem on his military leadership. Varney suggests that this personal issue may have influenced significant outcomes during the war, prompting readers to consider the broader implications of personal flaws on historical events.

Writing Style and Tone

Frank P. Varney's writing style in General Grant and the Rewriting of History is analytical and well-researched, making complex historical arguments accessible to both scholars and general readers. The tone is scholarly yet engaging, encouraging readers to rethink preconceived notions about historical accuracy and the accounts that are regarded as definitive. Varney's methodical approach in juxtaposing various historical documents against Grant's memoirs lends credibility to his critique, while his clear and persuasive prose maintains reader engagement throughout the book.

Criticism

While Varney's work is praised for its detailed research and insightful analysis, some readers might find the book's critical stance toward a revered historical figure like Ulysses S. Grant somewhat controversial. The idea of re-examining such a significant part of American history can be challenging for those who hold Grant in high esteem. However, Varney's intent is not to malign but to provide a more nuanced understanding of historical narratives, which might not resonate with everyone.

Awards and Recognition

General Grant and the Rewriting of History has been recognized as an invaluable contribution to Civil War studies. It has received praise from the Midwest Book Review, which recommended it highly and acknowledged its role as a sharp caution against relying too heavily on any single historical account.