I Am Perhaps Dying

Brief Summary

"I Am Perhaps Dying" by Dennis A. Rasbach serves as a medical supplement to "The War Outside My Window: The Civil War Diary of LeRoy Wiley Gresham, 1860-1865," edited by Janet Elizabeth Croon. The book delves into the medical aspects surrounding the life and experiences of LeRoy Wiley Gresham, a young man suffering from debilitating health issues during the American Civil War. Through meticulous historical research and medical analysis, Rasbach enriches the original diary with insights into the medical practices of the time, shedding light on the challenges faced by Gresham as he coped with his illness amidst the chaos of war.

Main Themes and Topics

A significant theme of "I Am Perhaps Dying" is the interplay between war and medicine. The book provides a detailed exploration of the medical practices prevalent during the Civil War era, highlighting how these practices influenced the treatment and understanding of diseases and injuries. Another central topic is the personal struggle of LeRoy Wiley Gresham, whose diary entries reveal not only his physical and emotional battles but also offer a window into the broader historical context of medical knowledge and societal attitudes towards illness during that period.

Writing Style and Tone

Dennis A. Rasbach's writing style in "I Am Perhaps Dying" is analytical yet approachable, balancing scholarly research with accessible narrative. The tone is empathetic and respectful, particularly in how it handles Gresham's personal story and the challenges he faced. Rasbach's ability to weave medical details with historical context is commendable, making complex medical concepts understandable to a general audience without losing the depth of information.

Awards and Recognition

While "I Am Perhaps Dying" may not have achieved mainstream literary awards, its specialized focus contributes significantly to Civil War historiography and medical history literature. The book has been recognized in academic circles for its in-depth analysis and contribution to understanding the medical history of the era, particularly in relation to personal accounts like that of LeRoy Wiley Gresham.

Criticism

Critics of "I Am Perhaps Dying" have pointed out that the book's specialized focus on medical aspects may not appeal to all readers, particularly those seeking a broader narrative about the Civil War. However, this critique is balanced by appreciation for the book's meticulous research and the unique perspective it offers. Some readers might also find the detailed medical terminology challenging, though it serves the purpose of providing an authentic depiction of the period's medical understanding.