Our War was Different

Brief Summary

Our War was Different by Albert Hemingway provides a compelling exploration of the Vietnam War through the lens of the Combined Action Program (CAP). The book delves into the firsthand experiences of the Marines who participated in this unique initiative, which sought to win the hearts and minds of the Vietnamese people by embedding Marines within local communities. With the CAP being one of the rare successes in Vietnam, Hemingway's work shines a light on a lesser-known aspect of the war, offering valuable insights into the challenges and achievements of these brave individuals.

Main Themes and Topics

One of the central themes of Our War was Different is the idea of unconventional warfare and the strategic shift from traditional military engagement to a more community-focused approach. The book highlights the CAP's mission to form alliances with local Vietnamese communities, underscoring the importance of cultural understanding and cooperation. Additionally, the narrative addresses themes of bravery, camaraderie, and the psychological impact of war on soldiers, capturing the complexity of their experiences in Vietnam.

Writing Style and Tone

Albert Hemingway's writing style in Our War was Different is both informative and engaging. He effectively combines detailed historical accounts with personal anecdotes from the Marines themselves, providing a balanced and vivid portrayal of the CAP. The tone is respectful and empathetic, honoring the courage and dedication of the men who served in this program. Hemingway's journalistic background is evident in his clear and concise prose, which makes the book accessible to both military enthusiasts and general readers alike.

Criticism

Critics of Our War was Different have noted that, while the book is rich in personal stories and firsthand accounts, it may lack a comprehensive analysis of the broader geopolitical and military strategies at play during the Vietnam War. Some readers may find the focus on the CAP limits the scope of the narrative, providing a somewhat narrow perspective on the conflict as a whole. However, for those specifically interested in the CAP and its unique role, the book remains an invaluable resource.