Place the Headstones Where They Belong

Brief Summary

Place the Headstones Where They Belong by Sherman L Fleek is a compelling historical account of Thomas Neibaur, a young soldier from Sugar City, Idaho, who became one of the most celebrated heroes of World War I. During the American Expeditionary Force’s key offensive in France’s Argonne Forest, Neibaur performed an extraordinary act of bravery by halting a German counterattack at Côte de Châtillon despite being severely wounded. His valor earned him the prestigious Medal of Honor, making him the first recipient from Idaho and the first Mormon to receive the nation's highest military honor. Yet, this book goes beyond the battlefield heroics to explore the tragic decline in Neibaur's life after his celebrated return home.

Main Themes and Topics

Fleek's book delves into themes of heroism and the personal costs of wartime accolades. It examines how public recognition can contrast with private struggles, illustrated vividly through Neibaur's life. The narrative addresses the challenges faced by veterans who return to civilian life after experiencing the horrors of war and the societal expectations placed upon them. It also discusses the emotional and psychological toll on soldiers who cope with the disconnect between their heroic wartime identity and the harsh realities of post-war life.

Writing Style and Tone

Sherman L Fleek writes with a meticulous attention to historical detail, creating a vivid portrayal of early 20th-century military life. His tone is both respectful and empathetic, capturing the emotional weight of Neibaur's personal journey. The prose is engaging and accessible, making the complex historical and emotional content approachable for readers. Fleek's narrative style effectively balances biographical elements with broader historical context, drawing readers into both the personal and the universal dimensions of the story.

Criticism

Some readers may find that the book, while rich in historical detail, occasionally falters in pacing, particularly in sections that delve deeply into military strategy and logistics. For those less inclined to military history, these parts might feel dense compared to the more personal elements of Neibaur's story. However, overall, the book’s thorough approach provides a comprehensive understanding of the broader circumstances surrounding Neibaur's life and legacy.