Revered Commander, Maligned General

Main Themes and Topics

"Revered Commander, Maligned General" by Michael E. Shay explores the life and military career of Major General Clarence Ransom Edwards, a pivotal yet often misunderstood figure in American military history. The book delves into Edwards' 40-year career, highlighting his significant contributions to the U.S. Army, spanning various conflicts and responsibilities. Central to the narrative is Edwards’ controversial relationship with General John J. Pershing, which has overshadowed his service, painting him as a political general rather than a skilled military leader. Shay's biography seeks to present a comprehensive and more nuanced view of Edwards, emphasizing his leadership qualities, loyalty, and the esteem in which he was held by his men.

The book covers Edwards' early life in Cleveland, his education at West Point, and his roles in significant military operations such as the Philippine-American War and his leadership in the Panama Canal Zone. It also outlines the formation of the 26th "Yankee" Division and Edwards' command in France, providing context to the disputes with Pershing that eventually led to his dismissal.

Writing Style and Tone

Michael E. Shay employs a well-researched and balanced narrative that draws heavily on primary sources to construct the biography of General Edwards. The writing is scholarly yet accessible, aiming to engage both military historians and general readers interested in World War I and early 20th-century American military history. The tone is respectful and objective, striving to illuminate the complexities of Edwards' character and career rather than merely defending or criticizing him.

Brief Summary (no spoilers)

"Revered Commander, Maligned General" presents Major General Clarence Ransom Edwards' journey from a young cadet in Cleveland to a notable U.S. military figure. While portraying the contentious circumstances surrounding his command dismissal by General Pershing, the book also shines a light on Edwards' commendable achievements and leadership traits. By offering a broader perspective on his career and contributions, Shay provides readers with an intricate portrait of an officer often overshadowed by historical controversy, yet worthy of recognition and understanding.