Savannah: Or a Gift for Mr. Lincoln

Brief Summary

Savannah: Or a Gift for Mr. Lincoln by John Jakes is a historical novel set against the backdrop of General William Tecumseh Sherman's infamous march to the sea during the American Civil War. The story unfolds in Georgia, 1864, as Sherman's Union army pushes through to the charming and historical city of Savannah. The narrative centers on the Lester family, particularly Sara, an enchanting widow, and her spirited twelve-year-old daughter, Hattie. They find themselves in a desperate struggle to preserve their rice plantation amidst the chaos of war. As the city braces itself for Sherman's advance, an unexpected encounter between Hattie and the general could alter their lives—and the course of events—unexpectedly.

Main Themes and Topics

A major theme explored in Savannah is the turbulence and divisiveness of war. Set during the latter part of the American Civil War, the book vividly portrays the drastic changes and challenges faced by individuals and families caught in the conflict. The resilience and determination of women, embodied by Sara and Hattie, are also central to the narrative, providing a poignant perspective on survival and adaptation in dire times.

Another significant theme is the notion of "gift" both literal and metaphorical. Sherman's march is historically noted for the severe consequences it had on the Confederacy, yet Jakes weaves a narrative that reexamines the general's conquests as a form of unexpected gift, particularly when he presents Savannah to President Lincoln. This serves as a reminder of the complexities of power, leadership, and legacy.

Writing Style and Tone

John Jakes is renowned for his meticulous attention to historical detail, and Savannah upholds his reputation as a master of the historical fiction genre. The writing style is brisk and engaging, moving swiftly through intricate plots without losing the essence of realism. Through exhaustive research and a strong grasp of the era, Jakes creates realistic and memorable characters whose humor and humanity provide a counterbalance to the harsh realities of war.

The tone of the book alternates between somber and hopeful. While the gravity of the war is ever-present, the story is interspersed with moments of levity and wit, showcasing Jakes's skill in blending serious historical context with engaging narrative storytelling.

Criticism

While Savannah has been praised for its rich historical context and character development, some critics have pointed out that the pacing can occasionally feel rushed, particularly given the significant events that unfold in the story. The scope of the narrative, though ambitious, sometimes leaves certain plot elements less explored, which might leave some readers wanting more depth in certain areas.

Despite these criticisms, the novel succeeds in creating an evocative portrayal of a significant historical moment, brought to life through the personal trials and triumphs of its characters.