Smedley D. Butler, USMC

Brief Summary

Smedley D. Butler, USMC by Mark Strecker is a compelling biography of an American Marine whose impact on 20th-century politics is often overlooked. The book delves into the life of Major General Smedley D. Butler, highlighting his transformation from a traditional military figure to an anti-corporate and left-wing populist. Strecker portrays Butler's pivotal role in exposing an alleged fascist plot to overthrow President Franklin D. Roosevelt, offering readers a detailed examination of the political landscape during a time when big business and military interests were deeply intertwined.

Main Themes and Topics

The central theme of the book is Butler's evolution as a political thinker and activist. Strecker extensively covers Butler's shift from standard Republican beliefs to outspoken criticism against corporate influence on politics and war. Through Butler's life story, the book navigates the complex political and economic issues of the early 20th century, including the rise of fascism, the impact of industrial capitalism, and the tensions between military duty and moral conviction. These elements highlight the intricate interplay between personal integrity and systemic corruption.

Writing Style and Tone

Mark Strecker's writing style is engaging and meticulously detailed, capturing both the intricacies of historical events and the personal dimensions of Butler's character. The tone is informative yet accessible, making complex political and historical subjects digestible for a wide audience. Strecker blends narrative with thorough research, effectively painting a vivid portrait of Butler and the era in which he lived. This approach not only informs but also keeps the reader captivated by bringing historical figures and events to life.

Criticism

While Smedley D. Butler, USMC is well-researched and comprehensive, some readers may find the dense historical content challenging, particularly those not well-versed in early 20th-century American politics. The book’s deep dive into political intricacies may overwhelm readers seeking a more conventional biography focused strictly on Butler's personal narrative. Moreover, the amount of detail supplied might sometimes slow down the pace of the storytelling, potentially impacting engagement for those seeking a quicker read.