Such Splendid Prisons

Brief Summary

Such Splendid Prisons by Harvey Solomon uncovers a remarkable yet largely forgotten chapter of World War II history. Following the attack on Pearl Harbor, the Roosevelt administration made the controversial decision to hold Axis diplomats and their associates in remote luxury hotels. This book sheds light on the lives of five key individuals among these internees—each having their privileged existence dramatically altered post-December 7, 1941. Through the lens of these characters, Solomon explores how war-time dynamics, including national loyalties and individual intrigues, played out within the confines of enforced luxury.

Main Themes and Topics

The central theme of Such Splendid Prisons revolves around the intersection of war, diplomacy, and human resilience. Solomon delves into the complex fabric of internee experiences, detailing how political decisions impact personal lives. The narrative explores themes of privilege, loyalty, betrayal, and adaptability amid unprecedented circumstances. Set against the backdrop of war, the book highlights the dichotomy between the internees' previous luxurious lifestyles and their uncertain futures. In addition, social tensions and racial prejudices of the time are brought to the fore, giving the reader a vivid portrayal of the multiple layers of conflict present within this unique wartime scenario.

Writing Style and Tone

Harvey Solomon's writing style in Such Splendid Prisons is engaging and meticulously researched. He masterfully combines historical facts with vivid storytelling, ensuring that the narrative remains both informative and compelling. His tone manages to balance seriousness with a nuanced understanding of the human elements at play. Solomon's narrative technique effectively brings out the personalities of the characters, making the historical figures relatable while maintaining their historical significance. The book is rich in details, which allows readers to immerse themselves fully in this nearly forgotten slice of history.

Criticism

While Such Splendid Prisons has been praised for shedding light on an obscure aspect of World War II, some readers may find the detailed historical context heavy at times, potentially slowing down the narrative for those less interested in the minutiae of diplomatic history. The focus on specific individuals might also lead to a narrower scope, occasionally limiting the broader perspective of wartime events beyond the closely followed experiences of the book's main characters. However, for history enthusiasts and those interested in personal stories from the era, this focus will likely prove to be a strength.