Super-Battleships of World War I

Main Themes and Topics

"Super-Battleships of World War I" by Angus Konstam delves into a fascinating and often overlooked chapter in naval history. The book concentrates primarily on the design and planning of a new generation of formidable naval vessels known as 'hyper-dreadnoughts' and battlecruisers that emerged as World War I drew to a close. The arms race among the United Kingdom, the United States, and Japan is a central theme, as each nation sought to leverage wartime experience to bolster their naval power.

Konstam's examination is thorough, covering the strategic rationale behind the designs and the technological advances intended to make these warships the apex of naval engineering. The impact of the Washington Naval Treaty of 1922, which abruptly halted construction and reshaped naval strategy, also serves as a significant focus in exploring how these "ships that never were" transitioned into aircraft carriers or were completely scrapped.

Writing Style and Tone

Angus Konstam's writing style is meticulous and authoritative, befitting his reputation as a naval expert. His tone throughout the book is scholarly yet accessible, striking a balance that caters to both enthusiasts of naval history and general readers interested in military history. He conveys complex technical details with clarity, supported by well-researched historical context that enriches the understanding of the geopolitical climate of the period.

Criticism

Some readers may find that the book occasionally dives too deeply into technical specifications and design details, which can be overwhelming for those without a keen interest in naval architecture. While this depth offers excellent insight for scholars and enthusiasts, casual readers might find these sections less engaging. Additionally, the focus on ships that were never completed might seem speculative to some, despite Konstam's reliance on historical plans and designs.

Brief Summary

"Super-Battleships of World War I" offers an in-depth look at the proposed naval advancements following World War I, emphasizing the 'hyper-dreadnoughts' and battlecruisers intended to be the next leap in naval warfare. The book explains how these ships were conceptualized amidst a post-war arms race, with each leading naval power striving to stay ahead through innovation. However, the resource-intensive nature of these projects and subsequent international agreements like the Washington Naval Treaty led to the cancellation of many of these ambitious designs. This transition reflects a pivotal moment in naval history, captured vividly by Konstam's expert narration and illustrations.