Telling Tales about Men

Main Themes and Topics

Telling Tales about Men by Lois S. S. Bibbings delves into the multifaceted perceptions and treatments of conscientious objectors in England during the First World War. The book examines the disparate narratives that emerged around these men, labeling them with terms ranging from "cowards" and "traitors" to "heroes" and "patriots." Each chapter meticulously articulates how objectors were seen through various lenses, such as those of criminals, deviants, and upstanding moral figures. This exploration is enriched by a broad spectrum of sources, including personal diaries, tribunal records, and government papers, which help paint a comprehensive picture of the objectors' diverse and complex identities.

Writing Style and Tone

Lois S. S. Bibbings employs an academic yet accessible writing style, blending meticulous research with narrative storytelling. Her tone is analytical, offering a balanced examination of conscientious objectors without bias. By integrating perspectives from various fields such as literary studies, sociology, and law, she crafts a nuanced portrayal that is both informative and engaging. This scholarly approach does not alienate general readers, making complex concepts relatable and understandable.

Brief Summary

Telling Tales about Men unravels the complex identities and social narratives surrounding conscientious objectors during World War I in England. Through six distinctive chapters, Bibbings examines a range of perceptions, illustrating how these men were simultaneously considered cowards and heroes, traitors and patriots. The book draws upon diverse sources, fostering a multifaceted understanding of the objectors' lives and the societal judgments they faced. By doing so, Bibbings contributes significantly to scholarly discussions on pacifism, militarism, and gender during the Great War.