The Colonel and the Pacifist

Main Themes and Topics

The Colonel and the Pacifist by Klancy Clark de Nevers delves into the themes of war, racism, and the moral complexities faced by individuals during times of national crisis. The book provides a detailed exploration of the infamous Executive Order 9066, which led to the internment of Japanese Americans during World War II. By focusing on the contrasting lives of Karl R. Bendetsen and Perry H. Saito, the narrative examines the dualities of power and victimhood, and how these intersect with personal and national identity. Another significant theme is the question of "military necessity" and its implications on civil liberties and ethical governance, a topic that echoes in modern times.

Writing Style and Tone

Klancy Clark de Nevers employs a narrative style that is both informative and engaging. Her tone is objective but empathetic, allowing readers to engage deeply with the historical context while also connecting on a personal level with the individuals involved. Through meticulous research and a keen attention to detail, de Nevers combines thorough historical analysis with compelling storytelling, making the book both educational and accessible. The interweaving of the personal stories of Bendetsen and Saito is skillfully done, providing a balanced perspective without losing the narrative's emotional depth.

Brief Summary

The Colonel and the Pacifist tells the intertwined stories of two men, Karl R. Bendetsen and Perry H. Saito, against the backdrop of one of America's most controversial wartime decisions. Bendetsen, an Army officer, played a pivotal role in the forced evacuation and internment of Japanese Americans—actions rooted in the concept of "military necessity." In contrast, Saito, a young Japanese American, finds himself on the receiving end of this policy, facing the challenges of internment. Despite never meeting, the lives of these two men represent the broader conflict between national security and individual rights. Their stories also continue into the post-war era, as the nation grapples with the consequences of its wartime actions.