The Edge of Glory

Brief Summary

The Edge of Glory by William M. Lamers is a meticulously researched biography of Major General William S. Rosecrans, a pivotal yet often overlooked figure in the American Civil War. The book explores Rosecrans's strategic acumen during key military campaigns, such as at Iuka, Corinth, and throughout the Tennessee battles. Despite his achievements, his career's decline after the Chickamauga defeat is portrayed as stemming more from his complex personality and problematic relationships with contemporaries like General Ulysses S. Grant, rather than solely from military failures.

Main Themes and Topics

The book delves deeply into the themes of military strategy and leadership during the Civil War, emphasizing the thin line between success and failure in military careers. Lamers highlights the contrast between Rosecrans's strategic brilliance and his ultimately flawed relationships with other military and political leaders, which significantly influenced his career's trajectory. The theme of personal downfall amid professional achievement is central to understanding Rosecrans's life story as presented in this narrative.

Writing Style and Tone

William M. Lamers employs a detailed and analytical writing style, presenting historical facts with clarity and depth. The tone is scholarly yet accessible, effectively engaging readers interested in Civil War history. Lamers's ability to blend biography with historical analysis makes the book both informative and enjoyable, even for those less familiar with the era.

Criticism

While Lamers's biography is commendable for its thorough research and engaging narrative, some readers may find the focus on military strategies and tactical details overwhelming. Additionally, the book's dense historical content might limit its appeal to a broader audience, making it particularly suited for readers with a strong interest in Civil War history or military biographies.