Their Promised Land

Their Promised Land by Ian Buruma - Book Review

Brief Summary

Their Promised Land by Ian Buruma is a beautiful and powerful recounting of his grandparents' love and life during the turmoil of the two world wars. The narrative is anchored by the extensive letters exchanged between Winifred and Bernard Schlesinger, which reveals not only their personal devotion but also paints a broader picture of cultural assimilation and survival against the backdrop of historic events. This family history provides a profound insight into the lives of a couple marked by steadfast love and shared resilience.

Main Themes and Topics

The book engages with themes of cultural assimilation, love, and resilience in the face of adversity. Central to the narrative is the exploration of Jewish identity and the challenges posed by anti-Semitism, even within the nation they cherished. Ian Buruma skillfully depicts the tension between cultural identity and national loyalty, as experienced by his grandparents, who were part of the high European cultural ideals rooted in their German-Jewish heritage. Additionally, the book emphasizes the strength of familial bonds, as demonstrated by the efforts to save Jewish children during the rise of Nazism.

Writing Style and Tone

Ian Buruma's writing is both tender and insightful, as he interweaves his own voice with the letters of his grandparents to construct a cohesive and evocative narrative. The tone conveys a deep respect and affection for Winifred and Bernard, while also critically examining the broader historical and social contexts of their lives. His narrative style allows readers to experience the intimate details of a loving marriage and a family's perseverance through dark times.

Awards and Recognition

Their Promised Land has been recognized for its heartfelt and nuanced portrayal of personal and historical narratives. It stands out for its unique perspective on World War history and has been praised by critics for its enriching contribution to both memoir and historical literature.

Criticism

While the book is lauded for its emotional depth and historical insights, some readers might find the extensive focus on correspondence overwhelming. The multitude of letters could potentially diminish the narrative pace for those looking for a more traditional storytelling approach. Nonetheless, this format is essential to conveying the authenticity and intricacy of Winifred and Bernard's relationship.