To Begin the World Over Again

Brief Summary (no spoilers)

To Begin the World Over Again by John C. Hulsman offers an insightful exploration into the life and legacy of T.E. Lawrence, more famously known as Lawrence of Arabia. The book delves into Lawrence's passionate advocacy for Arab nationalism following World War I and his determined efforts to establish a template for nation building in the Middle East. Hulsman paints a vivid picture of Lawrence's endeavors to hold the British accountable for their promises to Arab allies and his enduring struggle against the redivision of the Middle East by Western powers at Versailles—a decision that has had long-standing repercussions in the region.

Main Themes and Topics

One of the central themes in the book is the conflict between colonial ambitions and the promise of self-determination. Lawrence's story is one of immense passion for Arab independence and the betrayal by Western powers, particularly the British. Hulsman highlights the moral and political dilemmas faced by Lawrence as he attempted to navigate and influence a path toward a fair and just solution for the people he had come to champion. The book also examines themes of leadership, loyalty, and the complexities of nation-building—a narrative that resonates today amidst ongoing challenges in the Middle East.

Writing Style and Tone

John C. Hulsman employs a narrative style that is both engaging and informative, weaving historical facts with vivid storytelling. The tone of the book is reverent and reflective, offering readers an intimate glimpse into Lawrence's character and his conflicted legacy. Hulsman succeeds in blending historical analysis with compelling biography, making for a captivating read that balances scholarly insight with an accessible narrative.

Criticism

While To Begin the World Over Again is praised for its detailed research and engaging narrative, some critics may argue that the book paints an overly sympathetic portrait of T.E. Lawrence, sometimes glossing over his shortcomings and the complexities of his personality. It may also be noted that Hulsman's focus on Lawrence's perspective means that the voices and perspectives of the Arab allies he sought to help are less prominently featured, which could offer a more rounded understanding of the events described.