What We Owe Iraq

Main Themes and Topics

What We Owe Iraq by Noah Feldman is a thought-provoking exploration of the ethical responsibilities and strategic imperatives involved in nation-building, focusing on the case of Iraq. Feldman addresses the geopolitical complexities and moral considerations of America's involvement in Iraq, examining why the U.S. is engaged in rebuilding the nation and what outcomes would signify success. The book emphasizes that nation-building efforts should prioritize the interests of the local populace over those of the occupier, to avoid turning such endeavors into colonialist scenarios. Feldman highlights the need for a more humble approach to nation-building, where providing security takes precedence over imposing western-style governance models. The author offers insights into the dynamics between American authorities and Iraqi citizens, addressing topics like the challenges of democratization and the ethical implications of military withdrawal.

Writing Style and Tone

Noah Feldman's writing in What We Owe Iraq is marked by clarity and an engaging narrative, accessible to both scholars and general readers interested in international relations and ethical governance. Feldman leverages his background as a constitutional adviser in Iraq to offer firsthand accounts and analyses, which lend authenticity and depth to his arguments. The tone is analytical yet empathetic, reflecting a balanced view of the moral and practical dilemmas faced in international interventions and occupations.

Criticism

Some critics of What We Owe Iraq argue that while Feldman provides a detailed critique of American strategies and the ethical considerations of the Iraq invasion, the book could delve deeper into alternative strategies or offer more decisive solutions to the issues it raises. Others suggest that while the author's insights are valuable, the complexity of the topic may require a broader range of perspectives to address its full scope comprehensively. Nonetheless, the book has been lauded for its thought-provoking nature and valuable contributions to the discourse on nation-building.

Brief Summary

In What We Owe Iraq, Noah Feldman examines the intricacies of America's involvement in rebuilding Iraq. He offers a critical analysis of the reasons behind the intervention and highlights the ethical responsibilities the U.S. bears as a nation-builder. Feldman stresses that the ultimate goal should be to empower a democratically elected government capable of maintaining order and self-governance. By putting forth a case for a focused and humble approach to international interventions, he presents a nuanced perspective on how to navigate the challenges of restoring sovereignty to a war-torn nation.