Between Mutiny and Obedience

Main Themes and Topics

Between Mutiny and Obedience by Leonard V. Smith explores the nuanced dynamic between French soldiers and their commanders during World War I. The book challenges conventional narratives that depict soldiers' experiences solely as victimization and instead presents a dialogue of resistance and negotiation within the military hierarchy. Smith focuses on the French Fifth Infantry Division, which displayed contrasting behaviors of heroism and mutiny during the war. The work delves into the concept of implicit and explicit struggles within the army ranks, emphasizing the pivotal role of noncommissioned and junior officers. These officers bridged the gap between command authority and the shared ordeals of ordinary soldiers, redefining the boundaries of how warfare was conducted through a mutual negotiation of behavior between ranks.

Writing Style and Tone

Leonard V. Smith employs a scholarly yet accessible approach in his writing. His analytical tone is underpinned by thorough research, drawing from a wide array of sources, including accounts from ordinary soldiers and prominent military figures like General Charles Mangin. Smith's narrative is carefully structured to illuminate the complexities of wartime experiences, balancing detailed historical evidence with compelling storytelling. The book is methodical in its presentation, providing readers with a clear understanding of the multifaceted interactions between soldiers and their superiors during World War I.

Brief Summary

Between Mutiny and Obedience offers a detailed case study of the French Fifth Infantry Division during World War I, highlighting its transition from esteemed performance to widespread mutiny, and back to regaining its elite status. The book reveals how an implicit bargaining process among the ranks influenced military conduct and authority. By examining various perspectives within the division, Smith illustrates the soldiers' agency in shaping the conditions of their service, ultimately negotiating the fine line between rebellion and compliance. Through this exploration, the book provides a fresh perspective on military culture during one of history's most tumultuous conflicts.